I have been really bad about reviewing each chapter of the books I am reading. I told myself I would so that it might help me remember what I have read a bit better. So here I go.
The Emergence of the Catholic Tradition has been really great so far – very heavy, but great. Simply put, Pelikan is giving an historical context of why the Christian Tradition took shape the way it did – particularly in the way of orthodoxy.
Chapter 1: Preparatio Evangelica
The foundation for Christianity, as religion, was certainly Judaism. However, the immediate de-Judaization of Christianity had to occur. Christianity was instigated by a couple handfuls of orthodox Jews and it needed to unidentify itself with Judaism. The Christian understanding of God was triune, not monotheistic. The Christian understanding of sacrifice was completed in the crucifixion, not in temples with animals. Yet, many of the doctrines from the Hebrew tradition, remained in the Christian tradition. Take for instance the emphasis on the Old Testament (a Christian category) scripture to aid in understanding faith and theology proper. At the same time, some of the doctrines from Judaism that remained should not have remained for they often originated in the first Christian heresies such as Simonian Gnosticism. Others were simply modified such as Justin Martyr’s understanding of the priesthood.
Of further note, Christianity also had a foundation of ancient philosophy to aid its beginnings. Many church theologians and apologists actually adopted or adapted “pagan” philosophical ideas to help develop their understanding of certain things like: the Trinity, the resurrection, eternality, the immortality of the soul (if such a thing existed – the question was up for debate at the time), etc. Of particular note, Clement of Alexandria was one who especially was fond of Platonic and Socratic thought. His doctrine of creation was owed more thanks to Plato than to Moses. So as in Judaism, some doctrines in philosophy were modified to fit the Christian understanding. Plato understood there to be a demiurge of the world that fashioned the “chaotic matter that was preexistent into the world as we know it.” Clement adapted that and said that God is the preexistent demiurge of the world and the chaotic matter. Boethius’ Consolation of Philosophy is the perfect example of how a church theologian was able to find the relationship between truth found in philosophy and truth found in faith and the Scriptures. (By the way, I highly recommend Consolation of Philosophy to anyone who is interested in philosophy of religion.)
It seemed that the “seed of reason” – or the preexistent Logos – was embedded in man and allowed these philosophers to learn truth though they knew not nor had faith in the eternal God.
Chapters 2 and 3 to follow.